Dedicated to the study of all things Biblical.
John - the Google says this ...http://undercovernun.net/post/761749110/im-not-a-universalist-but-god-may-be
I tracked it even further. To the book:http://www.amazon.com/Exclusion-Embrace-Theological-Exploration-Reconciliation/dp/0687002826From comments -- page 299.But he says this in summarizing a quote from Moltmann -- and evens says, I have heard that, "I am not a universalist, but God may be." which he himself puts in quotes. So I don't know if you can really attribute the quote to him. He, himself suggests it's a known phrase.
Kenny - thanks for taking that further. I just did a quick search and grabbed the first hit result. I wondered if it was legit.
Kenny and Mike, thanks! I heard NT Wright use it recently, but he just says "some theologian". I think it is a good quote, but wonder if it is more urban legend.
John - I heard Wright use the same quote. Probably in the same talk that you saw/heard. I agree, it is a good quote and also that it might be an urban legend. I'll keep my ears open and let you know if I find out who said it.